XPENG MONA L03: The Greatest Base Tesla Mannequin Y Competitor?

---

Assist CleanTechnica’s work by means of a Substack subscription or on Stripe.

---

When trying on the new MONA L03, which not too long ago went on presale, it struck me that this is likely to be the closest competitor to the bottom RWD Mannequin Y. The automotive higher suits the extra premium priced Tesla, regardless of being positioned a category under XPENG’s G6 of their lineup.

Over time, there have been a number of headlines touting completely different fashions as the subsequent “Mannequin Y killer.” Nevertheless, these automobiles are inclined to attempt to beat the Mannequin Y by being extra than the Mannequin Y. Extra measurement and extra energy. Extra vary. Extra superior energetic suspensions and 4-wheel steering. Much more luxurious facilities, screens and bodily controls. Extra dampening to cut back NVH. Extra sculpted surfaces. Extra premium supplies… simply general extra. However one of the best competitors could not come from simply making an attempt to supply extra.

A Nearer Comparability

As compared, the XPENG MONA L03 affords a bit greater than the Mannequin Y in some areas and rather less in others. Arguably, there are a number of areas that XPENG executes higher with out including extra amount. It isn’t making an attempt to be extra in each manner. In some methods, which will make it extra compelling for a lot of clients, together with present Tesla homeowners.

At 4650 mm lengthy, the MONA L03 is shorter than a Mannequin Y (4794 mm) and a bit of longer than a RAV4 (4600 mm). Different measurements are basically the identical because the Y. Based mostly on regulatory filings, curb weight for the EV begins at 1,855 kg, making it a bit of lighter than the Mannequin Y.

The L03’s 5.25 m turning radius is tighter than the Mannequin Y at roughly 6 m. Each have impartial suspensions and rear wheel drive. Nevertheless, all variations of the L03 have adaptive dampers, whereas the Y affords the know-how on Efficiency trim. Together with the marginally lighter weight, shorter overhangs and better maneuverability, the Mona ought to deal with properly. Probably higher than the bottom trim Y. Nevertheless, we should drive it to know for positive.

The L03 has an 183-kW motor and accelerates to 100 km/h in 6.6 seconds. That’s 0.7s slower than the bottom RWD Mannequin Y in China, however 0.4s quicker than the bottom configuration within the US or Germany (0-100 km/h 7.2s). Whether or not the motive force notices the distinction will probably rely upon the tuning, simply as many individuals have thought that the Tesla felt quicker than it really was when in comparison with some rivals. When it comes to energy score, the L03 has much less on paper, however it’s successfully comparable.

The L03 affords ranges of 525 km or 625 km. The bottom Mannequin Y in China slots in between the 2 trims at 593 km. All beneath the identical CLTC score. The L03 additionally costs from 10-80% in 18 minutes, which is a bit quicker than the Mannequin Y at 25 minutes. Nevertheless it isn’t as quick as the newest flash charging fashions from different producers. A bit higher than the Tesla, however comparable.

On the within, the MONA L03 has a bit of extra rear seat leg room however claims much less cargo house. Because of Tesla utilizing non-standard measurements as much as the roof, reasonably than the trade commonplace measurement as much as the seatbacks, the distinction just isn’t as large because the producer claims would point out. Nevertheless, XPENG makes up for a few of the smaller capability with better utility, together with 8 magnetic mounting factors, 5 threaded mounting factors and peg boards within the rear for added attachment factors. As well as, it has a cargo drawer beneath the rear seat and 37 different storage places across the car. So, cargo useability is comparable, even when the amount just isn’t extra.

Up entrance, the L03 does have a number of extra bodily controls for the motive force across the steering wheel in comparison with the Y, and you may open the glove field with no need the touchscreen. Nevertheless it has far fewer bodily controls than premium XPENG fashions or many opponents. A 26.8” W-HUD supplies info to the motive force, however there may be not the proliferation of screens discovered in lots of Chinese language vehicles. XPENG’s voice assistant can be highly effective and can be utilized for a lot of features, however that doesn’t add visible muddle. A bit extra by way of driver shows and bodily controls, however not dramatically extra. Akin to the Y.

Staying on the inside, 72% of the surfaces within the L03 are gentle contact. XPENG calls the inside high quality a “class above,” which looks as if an apt description. Lots of the twenty audio system are behind steel grilles. The entrance seats have heating, air flow and 14 factors of therapeutic massage, whereas with the ability to recline to a zero-gravity place. Design is a little more fascinating than the Mannequin Y however nonetheless restrained and minimalist. Whereas it doesn’t include as many screens as a few of XPENG’s different fashions, powered attachment factors give individuals the flexibleness so as to add them to the entrance seatbacks for rear passengers. Total, the inside high quality appears arguably a bit higher, however it isn’t extra inside.

The L03 has 5mm thick tempered glass within the aspect home windows, however not the laminated glass within the Tesla. Mixed with energetic noise cancelling, the L03 claims 2-3 decibels decrease inside noise than the Mannequin Y whereas driving. That could be a important discount, though each are already quiet.

The outside of the L03 was designed by former Ferrari designer JuanMa López, who beforehand designed the Purosangue. XPENG in contrast the designs, however the L03 is a little more restrained than the Ferrari. Each are arguably higher trying than the Luce. In comparison with the Y, the L03 is extra sculpted, however not excessive or garish. The lighting signature can be a bit extra subtle on the L03. The yellow fastened calipers on variations with 20” wheels give the L03 a sportier look, extra like a Mannequin Y Efficiency. The L03 is arguably extra visually fascinating intimately than a Y, however it takes the acquainted SUV Coupe form. As well as, the 0.228 drag coefficient is akin to the Y (which claims 0.22), and considerably higher than the Ferrari Luce (0.254).

The MONA L03 can be constructed to have tight panel gaps between 3.25 and three.5 mm. Although Tesla has improved considerably in comparison with what they beforehand produced, L03 panel gaps are nonetheless tighter and extra constant than what might be discovered on a present Mannequin Y. So, whereas the physique isn’t larger, it’s arguably constructed extra exactly.

When it comes to intelligence, the XPENG comes commonplace with 750 TOPS of computing energy, and high spec fashions have 1500 TOPS, which supplies a bit extra processing headroom for future VLA 2.0 updates. That offers each trim ranges extra computing energy than HW4. XPENG additionally has a dozen ultrasonic sensors, helpful for parking in tight areas. Nevertheless, each clever driving techniques are vision-based, as a substitute of utilizing LiDAR and different long-range sensors. Whereas VLA 2.0 tends to be smoother and extra succesful in dense city environments, general, it’s the most comparable system to FSD amongst opponents.

Because of how VLA 2.0 learns, extra processing is finished onboard. Mixed with superior simulation, this lets the self-driving techniques shortly enter extra international markets. As such, not solely will the L03 launch in 64 markets, however may even have the ability to provide its clever driving capabilities in these markets. XPENG’s clever driving system could quickly be out there in additional markets than FSD.

The automotive can be launching with 5 stars throughout ANCAP, CNCAP and Euro NCAP security testing. Some Chinese language automakers are withholding their greatest fashions from some markets. However XPENG is launching as a world car. That international footprint will rival the Y throughout most main markets (in fact, excluding the US).

Arguably Higher, However Not Extra

When taking a look at many opponents, within the means of including extra to attempt to achieve a bonus, one thing will get misplaced. Including extra measurement and energy tends to extend weight, which tends to require a bigger battery, which will increase the burden additional. Drivers can really feel that weight, even when the energetic suspensions and bigger motors on some opponents result in higher quantifiable efficiency. The majority and weight could make the automotive really feel slower, even when it measures quicker. Extra screens and bodily controls are desired by many individuals, however some desire the “minimalism” of Tesla. Some individuals additionally desire the smaller footprint, particularly given the smaller European garages and parking areas

In a number of areas, the L03 is a bit higher than the bottom Mannequin Y. Among the applied sciences are extra superior. Higher maneuverability, charging, inside facilities, noise discount, supplies… however it isn’t making an attempt to be extra of a car. In some methods, it’s a higher Mannequin Y competitor than XPENG’s G6, which is extra of a automotive.

The L03 measures a bit of smaller and rather less highly effective than the Y. Nevertheless, the car compares to the Mannequin Y in the same option to how the Tesla compares to lots of the automobiles designed to compete towards it. Whereas I’ve but to drive it, I’ve a sense that the L03 will likely be of the same character to what drives individuals to the Y, regardless of it being much less of a car on spec sheets. In spirit, it’s probably one of the best competitor to the Mannequin Y.

One Space The place The MONA L03 Is Considerably Much less

In accordance with XPENG, the L03 is constructed round affordability and the wants of younger individuals. Tesla has been very profitable at convincing patrons that their price reducing measures are options. Within the L03, comparable measures additionally considerably enhance the affordability of the car.

The MONA L03 EV begins at 142,800 RMB ($21,018 USD) for the 525 Max trim as much as 152,800 RMB ($22,490) for the 625 Max, with the numbers indicating vary in km. Shifting as much as the Extremely SE trim provides 1500 TOPS of computing energy for prolonged clever driving functionality, with pricing from 155,800 RMB ($22,931) for the 525 Extremely SE as much as 165,800 ($24,403) for the 625 Extremely SE. Of be aware, these are presale costs, and last costs are usually a bit of decrease in China, whereas additionally providing a number of extra choices.

For comparability, the bottom RWD Mannequin Y with 593 km of vary and Tesla Driver Help included involves 327,500 RMB ($48,203). Over twice as a lot cash for a comparable car. Tesla additionally affords fashions with extra energy and extra vary for extra money. And the provide the bigger Mannequin YL with extra room. Many different opponents additionally provide automobiles that provide extra room, vary and energy. However this comparability isn’t about “extra.”

For one thing a bit completely different, there may be additionally an EREV model of the L03, which begins at 149,800 ($22,019) in Max trim as much as 161,800 ($23,815) in Extremely SE trim. This model has 315 km of WLTP battery vary, which needs to be greater than sufficient to cowl each day commuting on electrical energy. 1015 km of extra vary is out there from the gasoline vary extender. For people who find themselves not able to go full BEV, it might be a pretty choice. Seemingly the closest out there car to a Mannequin Y in EREV kind.

After all, we’ve but to see last pricing or how a lot the MONA L03 will price in international markets. Nevertheless, the L03 is more likely to price lower than XPENG’s G6, which tends to be priced under the Mannequin Y. So, it’s more likely to be a pretty worth in markets the place it’s out there. We even have but to drive the car on the highway, to see if it lives as much as its promise. Whether or not or not it’s higher than the Y will finally rely upon the execution. XPENG may additionally come out with different variations of the L03 sooner or later that compete with different Mannequin Y trim ranges. Nevertheless, by not making an attempt to be extra of a car than the Y, the MONA L03 may grow to be a extra compelling car for a lot of clients.

Are you able to consider a greater base Mannequin Y competitor?