Why Have Automakers Written Off $55 Billion In EV Investments?

Assist CleanTechnica’s work by way of a Substack subscription or on Stripe.


Or assist our Kickstarter marketing campaign!

An article title caught my consideration right now for a few causes. The title of the article is: “Main Automakers Have Written Off $55 Billion After Overestimating EV Demand.”

Hmm….

To begin with, the factor that jumped out to me was $55 billion. That’s numerous freakin’ cash! The newest announcement contributing to this was additionally the largest. Stellantis simply wrote off $26 billion of EV funding. Beautiful. Unbelievable. Horrifying.

Ford wrote off one other almost $20 billion, which triggered numerous dialogue on this matter already.

Taking a step again, it’s enormously disheartening to see that this a lot cash being invested into EVs was simply all of the sudden dropped and written off as a supposedly ineffective and dead-end endeavor. It’s surprising, and in addition a massively unfavorable signal for the place we’re headed with the local weather.

However why was the $55 billion written off? Are automakers giving up on their EV plans as a result of they overestimated EV demand?

Nicely, the plain reply is definitely an important one: US coverage modified dramatically when Donald Trump took workplace and Republicans took management of the Home of Representatives in addition to the Senate. EV subsidies have been killed, the Trump administration is making an attempt to kill EV charging tasks, and, the truth is, the entire system put in place for the federal government to drive automakers to make extra gas environment friendly automobiles and pollute much less is being annihilated — even though it has been in place for many years and is nice for shoppers and the general public at giant. When the entire breadth of US coverage centered on encouraging automakers to supply and promote EVs will get bombed, automakers lose the motivation to supply and promote EVs. That’s trigger #1.

There’s, nonetheless, an obvious drawback getting sufficient clients to purchase EVs on the worth factors automakers need. Maybe a part of this was overestimating client curiosity. Nevertheless, I do suppose there are different notable elements at play, akin to:

1. Automakers haven’t been very efficient at advertising EVs, at explaining to buyers why they need to need an electrical automotive greater than a gasoline one. Actually, I believe they’ve been horrible at this. They rarely actually clarify to individuals why EVs are higher.
2. Auto sellers are the principle conduits of automaker concepts and eventual actuality, and auto sellers appear very bored with promoting EVs. They typically have one EV specialist, and good luck being on the vendor on the proper time to go on a take a look at trip with him/her. Even in case you do get the EV specialist, they typically aren’t very thrilling or helpful in any respect. They merely know a bit extra of the fundamentals concerning the EV(s) the automaker sells. Total, although, good luck ever discovering an auto vendor that’s tremendous into EVs and promoting a lot of them. They sometimes simply wish to transfer what’s best and quickest to maneuver, and what will get them probably the most income, together with recurring service and upkeep income.
3. You actually do should scale up EV manufacturing with the intention to drive prices down and get probably the most advantages out of a mannequin. Have automakers merely given in too quickly or not tried exhausting sufficient to scale up, decrease prices, and promote hundreds of thousands of EVs?

Anyway, choose a aspect in case you like — do shoppers simply not need EVs, or have a wide range of authorities and company elements stifled EV schooling and EV adoption?

Additionally, humorous how multiple out of each 4 European new automotive buyers purchased an EV in December and one out of each 5 did so in 2025 as an entire. Humorous how 33% of new-car gross sales in China the place totally electrical automobile gross sales final yr. Automakers can discover EV consumers there simply sufficient, however not within the US?