We Shouldn’t Mourn The Cut price-Basement LEAF S

Help CleanTechnica’s work by way of a Substack subscription or on Stripe.

When the information broke lately that Nissan is indefinitely delaying the entry-level “S” trim of the 2026 LEAF, the web reacted with the same old refrain of doom: “One other reasonably priced EV bites the mud,” “Why doesn’t anybody wish to promote an affordable automotive?”

I get it and I’ve shared related sentiments up to now. I’ve spent years writing in regards to the want for reasonably priced EVs, and I’ve put tens of 1000’s of miles on budget-friendly vehicles just like the Bolt EUV and my outdated 2018 LEAF. I do know firsthand that not everybody wants (or can afford) a $70,000 towing rig or luxurious sedan. Even $30,000 is out of attain for many individuals, so cheaper EVs needs to be celebrated, proper?

However, let’s be actual for a second: We’re sitting in 2026. Compliance vehicles are lifeless, and arguably have been for years. Early adopters all have not less than one EV within the driveway. To succeed now, an EV has to satisfy a a lot stricter set of expectations than the EVs of yesteryear, and a lower cost can solely make up for a lot.

Compliance Automobile Considering

On paper, the LEAF S sounded just like the dream we’ve been asking for: a brand-new EV for round $27,000, and maybe cheaper. However whenever you have a look at what you may really be getting for that cash (a 52 kWh battery and roughly 210 miles of vary), the maths begins to disintegrate, particularly in case you drive wherever outdoors of a dense metropolis.

I’ve lived with a 240-mile Bolt, and I’ve pushed throughout the nation with one, and I did it towing a small trailer. 240 miles is unquestionably workable, but it surely’s sufficient to present some anxiousness for regional driving.

However 210? That’s actually pushing it. When you consider freeway speeds (particularly out right here within the West the place pace limits are 75–80 mph), winter climate, headwinds, or a little bit of battery degradation, that “210 miles” rapidly turns into 140–160 real-world miles. That’s not a highway journey automotive. That’s a “hope I make it to the following charger” automotive in some areas.

Sure, I do know that 210 miles covers over 90% of individuals’s drives. It in all probability covers all the pieces however the occasional highway journey. However no person outdoors of the early adopter sphere needs to pay a brand new automotive worth for even 98–99% of a automotive. Folks count on a brand new automotive to each cowl the native drives and take them throughout the nation on demand.

100 kW Charging Ain’t Gonna Minimize It

The larger concern, and the one that offers me flashbacks to my outdated #Rapidgate LEAF, is the charging pace. Whereas the remainder of the brand new LEAF lineup will get an honest 150 kW peak, the smaller battery within the S would have been bodily capped at round 100 kW. It might have seemingly acquired round that pace fairly persistently with liquid cooling, however that’s nonetheless 33% slower than not solely the higher LEAF trims, however different low cost automobiles just like the Equinox EV, the brand new Bolt that’s going to be on supply for a restricted time, and quite a few different EVs.

We aren’t in 2018 anymore. If you pull as much as an Electrify America station subsequent to a used Hyundai IONIQ 5 that’s charging in 18 minutes, do you actually wish to be caught there for 45 minutes to get sufficient juice to succeed in the following city? I’ve spent sufficient time sitting in Walmart parking heaps ready on a sluggish cost to let you know: it will get outdated, quick. Whereas it’s robust to please the individuals who need gasoline charging speeds, there’s an unlimited distinction between 20 minutes (time to go to the toilet and stretch your legs) and 45 minutes (sufficient time for a meal).

Launching a 100 kW automotive in 2026 would have simply bolstered the worst stereotypes about EVs. It might haven’t solely damage the picture of EVs as a complete, however it will have made individuals assume that the higher LEAF fashions with higher charging curves and vary are lower than they are surely.

The “Good Cash” is Elsewhere

The ultimate nail within the coffin is the existence of the LEAF S+.

For about $3,000 extra, you get a 75 kWh battery, over 300 miles of vary, and sooner charging. There is no such thing as a world the place saving $50 a month on a cost is value shedding practically 100 miles of vary. It’s the distinction between a automotive that may deal with a shock detour and one which leaves you sweating on the facet of the interstate.

And in case your price range is strictly capped at $27,000? You shouldn’t be a stripped-down new automotive anyway. You have to be wanting on the used market. For that worth, now you can seize a 2023 Tesla Mannequin 3 or an IONIQ 5 that can cost circles round a hypothetical LEAF S. And in case you’re proud of much less vary and slower charging? A variety of used EVs can be found (together with nearly new Bolt EUVs) for $10,000 much less.

There simply wasn’t a market area of interest for a automotive with LEAF S specs.

Conclusion

We shouldn’t mourn the lack of the “Low cost LEAF.” It was a car that might’ve been constructed to hit a worth level on a billboard, not meet the wants of a driver in the true world. It might’ve damage Nissan. It might’ve damage EVs as a complete when non-early adopters discovered that it had severe limitations.

What stays is the LEAF S+. At $29,990, it’s a 300-mile EV with liquid cooling (lastly!) and a NACS port that may be tailored to cost on CCS. That could be a professional win. Nissan trimmed the fats, and what’s left is arguably one of the best worth within the American automotive market immediately. The plus variant that’s accessible now is among the greatest {dollars} per kWh offers round, too.

If something, Nissan has realized from its previous errors (the #Rapidgate fiasco) and expertise promoting second-generation LEAF S fashions. We needs to be glad the corporate didn’t go laborious on value reducing like this once more.

We must also hope that different producers are good and keep away from making this type of mistake. Constructing an EV with outdated specs, whether or not it has a Datsun-style Nissan badge, a bowtie, or a V and a W in a circle, gained’t work out. The naked minimal immediately might be 250 miles with 10–70% charging that lands beneath a half hour.

Featured picture: My outdated 2018 Nissan LEAF S charging at an RV park in Lordsburg, New Mexico.