The Europe Automotive Market Is within the Grip of the Osborne Impact

Assist CleanTechnica’s work by way of a Substack subscription or on Stripe.

The European automobile market and the Osborne impact was the subject of an article I wrote almost 7 years in the past. I made daring predictions for the longer term, and as all predictions of the longer term, they had been mistaken. I ought to have written a followup on it, however I didn’t predict the COVID pandemic in 2020 or the invasion of Ukraine in 2022. Each did have massive repercussions for the European automobile market. The statistics for 2020 as much as most of 2023 had been influenced a lot by these two disasters that an interpretation of the affect of the invisible hand in the marketplace was unimaginable. The predominant affect was the drive majeure of those disasters.

However all issues go and the market has recovered from disruptions. Now I’ve the statistics for 2019 in addition to H2 2023 and later to have a look at. Not that these numbers are good — the irresponsible German reduce in incentives in late 2023 was clearly felt within the EU+ statistics, an outlier usually faraway from a statistics analyses. Combining these with numerous feedback from folks within the automobile market, like executives, editors of automotive magazines, fellow journalists, and the quite a few folks leaving their ideas within the feedback part of posts on social media, the conclusion could be very clear. The market is within the grip of the Osborne impact.

I used statistics printed by ACEA to make this desk beneath. The 2025 numbers are projections based mostly on the primary 10 months.

When taking a look at this desk, 2024 was a particular yr. There was the 144,000 drop in BEV gross sales in Germany following the top of buy subsidies in late 2013. There was additionally delayed demand due to the various new fashions of mannequin yr 2025 that the carmakers wanted with a purpose to adjust to the brand new CAFE thresholds for CO2 gr/km. It’s regular within the automobile trade for a mannequin to have fewer gross sales simply earlier than an improve. It’s not regular {that a} full class of autos has an improve on the similar second. With out the German subject, the 2019–2024 progress of BEVs would probably have been round 490% in comparison with 2019. The general gross sales would even have been barely higher. However the progress of BEVs can not fully compensate the shrinking demand for ICE.

A refresher on what the Osborne impact is: Over 40 years in the past the British Osborne house pc was an enormous gross sales success. When its successor was introduced a few yr earlier than it got here to market, gross sales of the present mannequin plummeted to shut to zero as a result of the shoppers delayed buy till the brand new mannequin was accessible. It precipitated the chapter of the corporate. It’s a lesson each advertising supervisor has discovered. Typically it’s used to dam gross sales of a competitor by promising a much better product sooner or later.

Now now we have the state of affairs that the general public is aware of that BEVs are higher driving machines than ICEVs. In addition they know that China is making BEVs which might be less expensive than the merchandise on the European market. Sloppy journalists evaluate the Chines pre-tax costs for fashions with out the various security options obligatory in Europe to the all-in drive-away costs in Europe. And final however not least, newer BEV fashions are extra succesful for the use circumstances Europeans count on from their vehicles. This case screams: “Osborne Impact – Hazard!”

The decline in ICEV gross sales signifies that the general public is realizing that its time is over. As a result of the general public is shopping for BEVs in smaller volumes for now whereas it isn’t shopping for as many ICEVs, we see a giant decline within the whole gross sales of vehicles. That is probably as a consequence of lack of selection for BEVs that can be utilized within the use circumstances required. It may also be that they’re nonetheless too costly and the general public is ready for decrease costs. To get again to the conventional 15 million passenger car gross sales a yr, the trade should supply extra economical and extra succesful vehicles.

An infomercial marketing campaign explaining what the most recent technology BEVs can do and the way secure they’re, what number of years/miles they can be utilized, how the most recent batteries have an extended service life forward of them, and the way simple it’s to discover a charger can even assist. Realizing that the ICEV period is over isn’t the identical as figuring out what the brand new regular is. Too many nonetheless consider that very soooon the promised hydrogen vehicles will change into the brand new commonplace bearer. It’s as much as the advertising departments to place this fairytale to relaxation. Preserving promoting ICEVs for one more 10 years whereas engaged on HFCEVs isn’t a practical possibility.

In all probability the largest downside for the European automobile trade is that the (advertising) administration doesn’t understand that the market is within the grip of the Osborne impact. As a result of all of them know precisely what to do and the way to beat the competitors after they encounter (or create) an Osborne impact. It’s advertising 101.