Shopper Experiences Finds Plug-In Hybrids Have 80% Extra Issues

Help CleanTechnica’s work by way of a Substack subscription or on Stripe.

Plug-in hybrids have been a controversial subject at CleanTechnica since 2014, when Chevrolet debuted the Volt. The Obama administration purchased a slew of them for presidency employees to drive, considering the transfer would save taxpayers cash on gas prices. It didn’t, for one easy purpose — nobody ever bothered to plug the rattling issues in!

Some consider plug-in hybrids as a “gateway” to battery-electric automobiles. Individuals who personal them will get used to plugging them in, so after they get a “actual” electrical automobile, doing so received’t appear so unusual. Driving on battery energy alone will introduce them to the quiet of an electrical automobile. Since most plug-in hybrids have some type of regenerative braking, folks will get to expertise that characteristic of electrical automobiles as nicely and by no means wish to give it up. Then there are all the opposite benefits of driving in electrons, like decrease value of gas.

Good Bye Vary Nervousness!

After all, the principle attraction for patrons of plug-in hybrid automobiles is — no vary anxiousness! That’s a biggie, as tales abound of motorists standing within the pouring rain on a darkish evening in South Succotash attempting to get a balky charger to begin delivering electrons to their automobile. Why danger it, when there’s a good quaint and dependable gasoline engine beneath the hood simply ready to be pressed into service?

For contrarians within the group, the arguments in opposition to plug-in hybrid comes all the way down to this. Why pay for 2 powertrains when one will just do positive? Regardless of coverage reversals, the variety of excessive velocity chargers is rising each day, making vary anxiousness primarily a factor of the previous. As Nike would possibly say — simply do it!

A complicating issue within the plug-in hybrid debate is that the time period can apply to a number of various kinds of automobiles. Some name the engine into use for those who depress the accelerator greater than 1 / 4 of an inch. Have to scoot away from a cease gentle? The engine kicks in. Have to go uphill? The engine roars to life. The engine in a real plug-in hybrid is there to supply electrons to the battery when wanted, to not energy the pushed wheels.

Producers have performed quick and free with authorities incentive applications, constructing automobiles that match the rules as an alternative of doing the job they’re purported to. After all, many will argue that policymakers ought to know the automakers will cheat if they’ll and may do a greater job of writing the foundations within the first place.

Particularly throughout the European Union, the automobile firms have foisted off 1000’s of so-called plug-in hybrids which might be so poorly designed, they really emit nearly as a lot exhaust air pollution as typical automobiles. However they certified for presidency incentives, which is the principle purpose they had been supplied on the market within the first place.

Lately, China has created a brand new class of auto known as prolonged vary EVs. Chinese language prospects had been usually disillusioned with the 20- to 30-mile vary of many plug-in hybrids and the federal government stopped offering coverage help for these marginal automobiles. EREVs are actually anticipated to have no less than 60 miles of battery-only vary and a few fashions have double that. Across the spritzer station at CleanTechnica’s luxurious but tastefully understated world headquarters, we predict EREVs provide the minimal efficiency folks ought to count on in the present day.

New Shopper Experiences Survey

Shopper Experiences has simply issued its newest reliability rankings for automobiles within the US and the outcomes are stunning. Its information exhibits plug-in hybrids undergo 80% extra issues than typical automobiles. Now to be truthful, a few of the worst performing fashions, just like the Ford Escape PHEV, are now not in manufacturing. Nonetheless, a number of current fashions such because the Mazda CX-90 PHEV, the Jeep Wrangler 4xe and Grand Cherokee 4xe, and the Volvo XC60 PHEV are included within the survey and all helped drag the reliability rankings for plug-in hybrid automobiles down.

That is unhealthy information for these of us who wish to see the EV revolution achieve momentum. Automobiles that spend extra time within the restore store as an alternative of on the highway drag the entire notion of electrical automobiles down. That is notably troubling at a time when the federal authorities is doing all it may possibly to destroy the EV revolution. That’s unhealthy sufficient, however producers aren’t serving to by constructing crappy automobiles which might be infested with glitches.

This 12 months’s survey drew responses from 380,000 automobile homeowners and coated automobiles offered from 2020 by way of 2025. When all the outcomes had been tabulated, Shopper Experiences discovered that hybrids, such because the Toyota Prius, have 15% fewer issues on common than automobiles with only a gasoline engine. EVs and PHEVs have about 80% extra issues on common than gas-only automobiles.

“Lots of the issues with EVs and plug-in hybrids are as a result of they’re newer designs in comparison with fuel expertise, so some kinks nonetheless proceed to be labored out,” says Jake Fisher, senior director of auto testing at Shopper Experiences. “By comparability, hybrids have been round for practically three a long time, and the expertise is tried and true.”

Usually, new fashions are extra troublesome than older fashions. Even new variations of typical automobiles are affected by reliability points. The survey exhibits Tesla is essentially the most improved automaker, as its automobiles — aside from the Cybertruck — have now matured sufficient to beat early reliability woes. The Mannequin Y is the now essentially the most dependable new EV, the survey exhibits.

EVs from Hyundai, Kia, and Genesis are the least dependable fashions from every model, largely because of a defective built-in charging management unit that may trigger a lack of energy whereas driving. “The draw back of sharing components and designs throughout a number of fashions and types is {that a} single fault can have an effect on a number of fashions,” says Fisher. Hyundai and Kia have additionally had vital points with their typical automobiles that share frequent parts.

Prime Firms Construct Prime Rated EVs

Lots of the hybrids with prime reliability are based mostly on already dependable designs or use hybrid powertrains which have improved incrementally through the years. “One main purpose why hybrids are usually extra dependable is that they’re largely made by manufacturers that make dependable automobiles, reminiscent of Honda, Lexus, and Toyota,” says Steven Elek, program chief of auto information analytics at Shopper Experiences.

By the identical token, producers who’re identified for constructing dependable automobiles additionally make dependable EVs. “Lexus is the third most dependable model in our 2026 survey, and the automaker’s RZ SVU is the second most dependable EV. Equally, BMW is the fifth most dependable model total in our survey, and its EVs are not any exception: The i4, i5, and iX all have common reliability.”

Jake Fisher provides, “Constructing a whole automobile firm from scratch is a Herculean enterprise and it may possibly take years to work out the bugs. Tesla appears to have graduated from the issues {that a} startup automaker faces, however different producers nonetheless have teething points.”

After a few years of manufacturing its CX-90 and CX-70 SUVs, Mazda completely redesigned each of them for the 2024 mannequin 12 months and reliability has plummeted in consequence. Mazda is now the bottom ranked Japanese automaker for brand spanking new automobile reliability.

Reliability for electrical automobiles from Basic Motors has suffered currently. Virtually each mannequin that makes use of the shared Ultium expertise — together with the Chevrolet Blazer and Cadillac Lyriq — has a reliability rating of beneath common or nicely beneath common. Even the Honda Prologue, which was constructed as a part of a short-lived partnership between Honda and GM, has below-average reliability, regardless of the Honda model’s excessive total rating, Shopper Experiences says.

A Lose/Lose Proposition

The takeaway from this 12 months’s survey, if there’s one, is that plug-in hybrids — no less than those supplied on the market within the US — are a lose/lose proposition for producers and their prospects. The herd mentality is making a spike in demand for plug-in hybrid automobiles. Scout Motors, the brand new division of Volkswagen, is backpedaling furiously in its quest to deliver battery-electric automobiles to market. In keeping with the most recent info, 80% of reservation holders have expressed a desire for plug-in hybrid powertrains as an alternative of purely electrical variations.

GM, Ford, and Stellantis are falling throughout themselves to get plug-in hybrid fashions into manufacturing. To not put too positive some extent on issues, some readers could recall when Cadillac tried to trip the diesel wave and rushed a diesel engine that was a reworked model of a standard gasoline V-8 into manufacturing. The outcome was a catastrophe that almost marked the tip of the Cadillac model.

We also needs to level out that most of the issues famous by these 380,000 individuals who participated on this 12 months’s survey had nothing to do with the bits that make the automobiles go and cease. As a substitute, they contain software program glitches within the infotainment and navigation techniques that are actually commonplace in most new automobiles.

Be that as it could, if I had been on the lookout for a brand new automobile in the present day, I’d remove any plug-in hybrids from my decision-making course of. Shopping for one is simply asking for bother. Vary anxiousness isn’t sufficient or a purpose to tackle the complications and frustrations of a automobile that spends extra time within the restore store than in your storage. In the case of the present crop of plug-in hybrids (Chinese language made EREVs could also be extra dependable), channel Nancy Reagan and simply say “no.”